October 8, 2013
Pay Ratio Disclosure
On September 18, the SEC proposed highly anticipated rules governing the ratio of CEO to median employee pay that public companies will be required to disclose in their proxy statements. In today’s blog, I provide a summary of the proposed rules.
Background
We’ve known this was coming since the Dodd-Frank Act was signed into law. The Act requires the SEC to adopt rules mandating that public companies disclose the ratio of CEO pay to that of the median pay of all other employees (see my blog entry “Beyond Say-on-Pay,” August 5, 2010). It’s taken a while for the SEC to propose the rules because, well, it’s a complicated topic and the SEC has a lot on its plate these days, including a host of other rulemaking projects under Dodd-Frank and the Jobs Act, not to mention investigating Rule 10b5-1 plans.
You Win Some
The Act requires that the ratio of CEO pay to median employee pay be based on “compensation” as defined for purposes of the Summary Compensation Table. So, in a worst case scenario, you could have had to prepare an SCT for all employees just to figure out the median employee compensation.
And, if you want, you can certainly still do that. But, for most companies, it’s about all they can do to put together the SCT for the 5+ execs for whom disclosure is required. So, instead, the proposed rules allow companies to figure out which employee represents the median based on any consistent, systematic method (e.g., based on W-2 income), then determine only that employee’s compensation as per the SCT. The pay ratio disclosure would then simply be the CEO’s pay as compared to the pay of the one employee that represents the median.
You Lose Some
That was the good news. The bad news is that the SEC has interpreted “all employees” to be literally all employees. That includes part-timers, seasonal, and temporary employees, and both US and non-US employees employed as of the last day of the company’s fiscal year. Pay for employees that were hired during the year can be annualized, but annualization is not permitted for seasonal or temporary employees. Likewise, location-based cost-of-living adjustments or full-time adjustments for part-time employees are not permitted.
More Information
For more information, see the NASPP Alert “SEC Proposes CEO Pay Ratio Disclosure Rules.” The proposed rules were issued just days before the NASPP Conference, so speakers at the Conference were able to address them during their presentations. In particular, Keith Higgins, the Director of Corporation Finance at the SEC, discussed the proposed rules in his keynote during the Proxy Disclosure Conference, and Mike Kesner of Deloitte provided a tutorial on the proposed rules in the session “Pay Disparity Workshop & How to Ensure Your Pay Practices Pass.” You can purchase the video of the Proxy Disclosure Conference or purchase the audio for Mike’s session.
Comments on the proposed rules can be submitted to the SEC until December 2, 2013.
– Barbara