June 24, 2014
409A Audits
The IRS has announced an audit initiative focused on Section 409A compliance. Frankly, I’m a little surprised that they haven’t undertaken this sort of audit initiative sooner–I’ve heard from practitioners that, up until now, Section 409A has rarely been a focus of IRS audits. Given the complexity of this area of the tax code and the fact that every time I have a question about it, my sources never seem to be entirely sure of the answer (and I sometimes get conflicting answers), it seems like 409A could be an untapped wealth of compliance errors for the IRS.
Who Are the Lucky Winners?
Some companies are just lucky. The IRS has picked 50 companies to be the subject of the audits, all of which have already been selected for employment tax audits–I guess the IRS is a believer of “when it rains, it pours.” The good news is that if you haven’t already been selected for an employment tax audit, you won’t be part of the initial 409A audit initiative.
What Is the IRS Looking For?
The audits will focus on deferral elections (both initial deferrals and re-deferrals) and payments (including payments to key employees upon separation of service). It’s pretty rare that we see deferral elections for stock compensation; only 29% of respondents to the NASPP’s 2013 Domestic Stock Plan Design Survey (co-sponsored by Deloitte Consulting) allow deferrals for time-based RSUs and only 24% allow deferrals for performance awards. Based on this, it seems that the audits will concentrate primarily on more traditional NQDC plans, rather than stock compensation.
This seems like a missed opportunity for the IRS–I’ve always found the application of Section 409A to stock compensation to be particularly confounding and full of traps for the unwary. Moreover, I think this is an area of the tax code that often is overlooked when we are thinking about potential concerns related to stock awards. But perhaps the IRS will expand to stock compensation in the next phase of the audit initiative.
The Next Phase?
I say “next phase” because this could be a precursor to a larger, more intensive audit of Section 409A compliance. In a memo on the initiative, Groom Law Group says “The IRS will assess what further steps, if any, to take after the results of these audits are in.” Now is a good time to get out ahead of this and perform your own self-audit of 409A compliance. In his blog on CompensationStandards.com, Mike Melbinger of Winston & Strawn points out that there is a corrections program available for some operational errors under 409A, but that the corrections program is no longer an alternative once you are the subject of an audit.
For more information, see the NASPP alert “IRS Conducting 409A Audits.”
– Barbara